# Compare locations

> Select two or more states, metros, counties, or cities in Explore to compare them side by side, in the right rail or a full metric-by-metric table.

## Before you start

- Comparison lives inside **Explore**, not as its own sidebar item. There is
  no standalone Compare screen; you build a comparison by selecting
  locations on the Explore map, table, or grid at whichever level you're
  viewing (**State**, **Metro**, **County**, or **City**).
- You need at least two selected locations at the same level before a
  comparison panel appears. See
  [Explore a location](https://kb.incenti.co/insights/explore-a-location.md) for how selection works at
  each level.
- Economic Development Districts compare differently — see
  [Explore EDD regions](https://kb.incenti.co/insights/edd-regions.md).

## Steps

### Select locations to compare

1. At **State** and **County** level, click a location on the map or its row
   in the table or grid. Each click adds to your selection; clicking a
   second, third, and so on location keeps building the set instead of
   replacing it.
2. At **Metro** level, tick the checkbox on a metro's row in the table, or
   click a bubble on the map or an entry in the **Top 5 Metros** card;
   either way adds it to the selection. Metro selection is capped at 5, and
   the cap is silent — a sixth click simply does nothing.
3. At **City** level, tick the checkbox on a city's row in the grid. This is
   a separate action from clicking a city to open its detail panel: the
   checkbox controls what's in the comparison, while clicking a row just
   opens that one city's details. City selection is capped at 5; trying to
   check a sixth shows "Compare holds up to 5 cities — remove one first."

State and County are the only levels where you can select more than 5
locations at once.

### Open the comparison panel

Once you have 2 or more locations selected, the right-hand rail turns into
the comparison panel described below. What the toolbar's **Compare** button
does depends on the level:

| Level  | Toolbar Compare button                                                          |
| ------ | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| State  | Appears at 2+ and opens the full-screen comparison                              |
| County | Appears at 2+ and opens the full-screen comparison                              |
| Metro  | Always visible with a count badge, disabled below 2, then opens the full view   |
| City   | Appears at 2+ but only closes the open city panel to reveal the comparison rail |

At City level, use **Full comparison** in the panel to open the full-screen
view — the toolbar button will not do it.

### Read the side panel

With 2 or more locations selected, the right-hand rail becomes a compact
comparison panel:

- A header reading "Comparing N states" (or metros, counties, cities), with
  a **Clear** link to drop the whole selection.
- If more than 5 locations are selected, a note like "Showing first 5 of 7
  selected" — the panel and the full comparison both cap at 5. Only State
  and County can get into that situation.
- One row per selected location, colored to match the rest of the panel,
  showing its name, a subtitle (population, or state and CDP status for
  cities), and its Composite Score. Click the **✕** on a row to drop that
  one location from the comparison.
- A **Full comparison** button that opens the full-screen view.
- A radar chart overlaying each location's Cost, Workforce, Risk, Quality,
  and Regulatory scores, so you can see shape differences at a glance. City
  level skips this: cities have no composite or category scores, so their
  panel goes straight from the location rows to the metric table.
- A metric-by-metric table grouped by category (Layer Scores, then each
  data-layer group). The best value in each row is shown in green with a
  trophy mark. At City level, a value inherited from the city's county
  (rather than measured at the city itself) carries a small "County" tag,
  and a value suppressed at that population size shows as "—".

_Screenshot: The Explore comparison panel: a Comparing N states header with Clear, selected-location rows with remove buttons, a Full comparison button, a radar chart, and a metric table with best-value highlighting._

### The colored dots

Each location in a comparison is given one of five fixed colors in the order
you selected them. The same color follows that location everywhere in the
comparison: its row in the panel, its line on the radar chart, its outline
on the map at Metro and City level, its bar in the **Score Breakdown**
chart, and its card in the full view. Remove a location and the remaining
ones keep their colors in order.

### How the best value is chosen

The green highlight and trophy mark the best value in a row, but only when
the row can actually be won:

- The metric must have a direction. **Population**, **Median Age**, **Metro
  GDP ($M)**, and **Per Capita Income** at metro level are direction-neutral
  — a higher number is neither better nor worse — so those rows never get a
  trophy.
- At least two locations must have a number on that row. If only one has a
  value and the rest show **—**, no trophy is awarded.
- Yes/no metrics such as **Right-to-Work** never compete, and **—** never
  wins.
- A tie awards the trophy to every location that ties.

### Open the full comparison

4. Click **Full comparison** in the panel, or **Compare** in the toolbar at
   State, County, and Metro level, to open the full-screen comparison view.
   It shows the same locations across the full width of the screen:
   - A header ("State Comparison", "Metro Comparison", "County Comparison",
     or "City Comparison") with a back button — **Back to Map** at State,
     County, and City level, **Back to Explorer** at Metro level.
   - A card per location with its name and score. State and County cards
     show population, Metro cards show the metro's short code, and County
     cards show the state abbreviation alongside population.
   - A **Layer Score Comparison** radar chart and a **Score Breakdown** bar
     chart (State, Metro, County only; City has neither).
   - A detailed comparison table grouped by category (for example Workforce
     & Demographics, Cost Factors, Risk & Environment, Quality of Life,
     Regulatory & Policy at State level), one row per metric, with the best
     value in each row highlighted in green. At Metro level each metric
     label carries the name of its source.

_Screenshot: The full-screen comparison view: location cards with scores, a Layer Score Comparison radar chart, a Score Breakdown bar chart, and a grouped detailed comparison table with best-value highlighting._

### Add, remove, or swap a location

5. From the full comparison view, click **Add State** (or Add Metro,
   Add County, Add City) and search for a location to add it, up to 5
   total. The button disappears once you have 5. Click the **✕** on any
   location's card to remove it. There's no dedicated swap action: removing
   one and adding another has the same effect.
6. Opening the full comparison with fewer than 2 locations selected shows an
   empty state instead ("Select 2–5 states to compare side-by-side across
   all metrics.") with buttons to go back to the map or add locations
   directly.

### City comparisons carry county indicators too

A city comparison adds a **County & city-source indicators** section below
the fourteen city indicators. Hovering a cell tells you whether the value
was measured for the city itself or inherited from its principal county, and
names the source and period. The section footer spells the rule out: native
rows are Census ACS 5-Year city estimates, county-labelled cells inherit
each city's principal county. See
[City-level data](https://kb.incenti.co/insights/city-level-data.md).

**For economic development organizations:**

Economic development organizations typically select their own state,
metro, or county alongside two or three competitor locations to see how
they stack up category by category, then pull the best-value highlights
into a pitch or marketing deck.

**For site selectors:**

Site selectors typically select every candidate location on a shortlist at
once and use the full comparison table to eliminate locations that lose on
a hard requirement, before narrowing to a final recommendation.

## What happens next

- At **State** level only, your selection (and so your comparison) is
  written into the page's URL as `?states=`, so copying and sharing that
  URL with a colleague reopens Explore with the same states selected and
  the same comparison panel available. Metro, County, and City comparisons
  are not reflected in the URL; a colleague needs to rebuild the selection
  by hand.
- There is no export or print action for a comparison. To get the underlying
  numbers, use **Export** on the Explore toolbar with the same locations
  selected — see [Export and CSV formats](https://kb.incenti.co/insights/export-and-csv-formats.md)
  — or click **Create report** to produce a comparative report.
- A standalone **Compare** tab existed in an earlier version of Insights.
  Old links to it still work: they redirect into Explore, carrying over a
  `?states=` selection if the old link had one, and land you on the same
  side panel and full comparison described here.

## Common questions

**Q: How many locations can I compare?**
A: Two is the minimum. Five is the maximum shown at every level — State and
County let you select more than five, but the panel and full comparison
still show only the first five, with a note saying so. Metro and City stop
at five selections outright.

**Q: Can I compare a state with a county, or a metro with a city?**
A: No. Comparison only works within one geography level at a time. Switching
levels in Explore clears your selection, so build your comparison after
you've picked the level you want.

**Q: At City level, why does the Compare button just close my city panel?**
A: At City level the toolbar **Compare** button only dismisses the open city
detail so the comparison rail underneath is visible. Use **Full comparison**
in that rail to open the full-screen view.

**Q: Why is Compare greyed out at Metro level?**
A: The Metro toolbar always shows the button, disabled with a count badge
until two metros are ticked. Tick a second metro and it becomes active.

**Q: Why can't I add a sixth metro — nothing happens when I click?**
A: Metro selection is capped at five and the cap is silent, so a sixth click
is simply ignored. Untick one metro to make room.

**Q: Why is there no trophy on the Population or Metro GDP rows?**
A: Those metrics are direction-neutral — bigger is not automatically better
— so no location can win them. Rows only get a trophy when the metric has a
direction and at least two locations have a number on it.

**Q: Why did nobody get the trophy on a row where one location clearly has
the best value?**
A: A row needs at least two numeric values to be compared. If the other
locations show **—**, there is nothing to compare against, so no highlight
is awarded.

**Q: What do the colored dots next to each location mean?**
A: They are the series colors for the comparison, assigned in selection
order. The same color identifies that location on the radar chart, the bar
chart, its card, and its outline on the map.

**Q: Can I export or print the comparison table?**
A: Not directly. Export the same selection from the Explore toolbar for the
raw numbers, or click **Create report** to generate a comparative report you
can download.

**Q: I don't see a Compare button. Why?**
A: You need at least 2 locations selected at the current Explore level.
Below 2, State, County, and City show no Compare button, and Metro shows its
button disabled.

**Q: Is this the same as the Compare tab under Incentives?**
A: No. That's State Incentive Benchmarking, which compares states'
incentive programs and award activity, not their economic and demographic
metrics. See [Incentive Intelligence](https://kb.incenti.co/insights/incentive-intelligence.md).

## Related

- [Explore a location](https://kb.incenti.co/insights/explore-a-location.md)
- [Insights overview and data coverage](https://kb.incenti.co/insights/overview-and-data-coverage.md)
- [How Insights scores are calculated](https://kb.incenti.co/insights/how-scores-are-calculated.md)
- [City-level data](https://kb.incenti.co/insights/city-level-data.md)
- [Export and CSV formats](https://kb.incenti.co/insights/export-and-csv-formats.md)
- [Explore EDD regions](https://kb.incenti.co/insights/edd-regions.md)
- [Incentive Intelligence](https://kb.incenti.co/insights/incentive-intelligence.md)
- [Ask Insights](https://kb.incenti.co/insights/ask-insights.md)
