# How Incentive Intelligence figures are computed

> How the Incentives screen normalizes dollar figures, builds the Incentive Competitiveness Score, labels tiers and sources, and classifies recipients.

## Two datasets, two methods

The **Incentives** screen reads two separate datasets, and the rules on this
page apply to one or the other, never both.

- **Incenti Subsidy Intelligence** is the award dataset — disclosed
  incentive deals that companies have already **won**. Everything about
  normalization, the Incentive Competitiveness Score, tiers, categories,
  source labels and the record cap applies to this dataset.
- **Incenti Program Intelligence** is the **Programs Offered** catalog —
  the incentive programs a state currently **offers**. Coverage tiers, the
  industry filter rule and the re-verification sweep apply to this one.

An award on record does not prove the program behind it still exists, and a
catalogued program does not prove anyone has claimed it. Read
[Incentive Intelligence](https://kb.incenti.co/insights/incentive-intelligence.md) for what each
tab shows; this page is only about how the numbers are produced.

## How dollar figures are normalized

Wherever the Incentives screen blends award dollars across states — the
**Tracked Value** KPI, the category treemap, the annual trend, per-state
value, medians and the **Compare** table — it uses a normalized view of the
award dataset rather than raw lifetime totals. Three adjustments are applied,
in this order:

1. **Awards from 2008 onward only.** Before 2008 the underlying disclosure
   is thin and uneven — a handful of states reach back decades while most do
   not — so lifetime totals mostly measure how far back each state's
   disclosure happens to go, not how much it awarded.
2. **Bundled megadeals excluded.** A bundled megadeal packages several
   mechanisms into one headline number, and a few of them dominate some
   states' totals outright. They are excluded from the blended figures and
   shown in full on the **Megadeals** tab instead.
3. **Extreme outliers capped, not dropped.** The remaining values are capped
   at the 99.9th percentile of that eligible set. A single mis-keyed
   multi-billion-dollar record can no longer swing a state's total, but the
   award still counts — at the cap.

### The "How this is normalized" footnote

Overview, the **Map** in ICS mode, **Compare**, **Explorer** and every state
profile carry a footnote beginning **How this is normalized:**. It prints
the live figures behind the three rules — the window start year, how many
bundled megadeals were excluded and their combined value, the cap's
percentile and dollar value, and how many awards it affected. It also notes
that property-tax relief covers economically equivalent mechanisms (PILOTs,
GPLET, tax-refund grants) in states without statutory abatement authority.

The footnote only renders where normalized figures are actually in use. Raw,
all-time numbers still appear on the **Explorer** tab, which lists award
records as reported, and on the printable **State Report**, whose **Total
Tracked** KPI is the raw lifetime figure. That is why the two can differ for
the same state.

## The Incentive Competitiveness Score

The **Incentive Competitiveness Score (ICS)** is a 0–100 index of how
competitive a state's incentive activity looks. It is a weighted blend of
four components, each itself scored 0–100:

| Component          | Weight | What it measures                                  |
| ------------------ | ------ | ------------------------------------------------- |
| Typical Award Size | 25%    | The state's median disclosed award                |
| Large-Award Share  | 30%    | Share of disclosed value in the two largest tiers |
| Recency            | 20%    | Share of disclosed value awarded in 2020 or later |
| Category Diversity | 25%    | How evenly value spreads across the 14 categories |

_Screenshot: The Incentive Competitiveness Score — State Rankings card: states ranked by ICS with each state's tracked value, and capped and limited-disclosure flags on the rows that carry them._

How each component is scaled:

- **Typical Award Size** is scored on a log scale: a median award of $1,000
  scores 0 and a median of about $3.2 million scores 100.
- **Large-Award Share** is the share of disclosed value in the **Strategic**
  and **Transformational** tiers. 0% scores 0; 85% or more scores 100.
- **Recency** is the share of disclosed value awarded in 2020 or later,
  used directly as the 0–100 score.
- **Category Diversity** measures the spread of value across the 14 award
  categories. A state concentrated in one category scores 0; reaching 95% of
  the maximum possible spread scores 100.

The ICS is computed once when the award dataset is ingested, over the **raw,
all-time** records. Setting a **Years** range or reading a normalized dollar
figure never changes it — which is why **Compare** and the state profile
footnote both say scores are computed across all years.

### Limited disclosure

A state is treated as having **limited disclosure** when its disclosed value
is under $50 million **or** it has fewer than 30 disclosed awards. There is
not enough on record to score those two components honestly, so the national
median is substituted for **Typical Award Size** and **Category Diversity**
(and for **Recency** too, when the state has no disclosed value at all).

These states show a grey ICS badge, an amber warning icon in the state
rankings, a **Limited** chip on the map hover card, and the line **Limited
disclosure — score uses national fallbacks** on the state profile. The score
is still shown — it is just a weaker signal than an ordinary one.

## Tiers, categories and source

### Award tiers

Every award falls into one tier by its disclosed dollar value:

| Tier             | Value                        |
| ---------------- | ---------------------------- |
| Micro            | Under $100,000               |
| Standard         | $100,000 to $1 million       |
| Major            | $1 million to $10 million    |
| Strategic        | $10 million to $100 million  |
| Transformational | $100 million and above       |
| Undisclosed      | No dollar value was reported |

**Large-Award Share** on Compare, the state profile and the ICS breakdown
means Strategic plus Transformational, measured by value.

### The 14 categories

Each award is mapped to one of 14 categories: Tax Credit / Rebate, Property
Tax Relief (Abatement / PILOT), Cash Grant, Tax Increment Financing,
Enterprise / Opportunity Zone, Workforce Training, Financing & Loans, Tax
Exemption, Cost / Fee Reimbursement, Infrastructure Assistance, Venture
Capital, Technical Assistance, Megadeal (Bundled), and Multiple / Other.
**Multiple / Other** is the fall-through for any award type that doesn't
match a known mechanism — it is deliberately not folded into Cash Grant.

### The six display groups

Mix bars and filter chips roll the 14 categories into six groups:

| Group                  | Categories it covers                                        |
| ---------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------- |
| Tax Credit / Abatement | Tax Credit / Rebate, Property Tax Relief                    |
| Cash Grant             | Cash Grant, Cost / Fee Reimbursement                        |
| Financing & Loans      | Financing & Loans, Venture Capital, Tax Increment Financing |
| Workforce / Training   | Workforce Training, Technical Assistance                    |
| Infrastructure         | Infrastructure Assistance, Enterprise / Opportunity Zone    |
| Exemption / Other      | Tax Exemption, Megadeal (Bundled), Multiple / Other         |

A bundled megadeal lands in **Exemption / Other** because it is several
mechanisms at once and cannot be attributed to any single group.

### Source: State, Local, Unknown

The **Source** column on **Explorer** records the level of government that
granted the award. It reads **State**, **Local**, or **Unknown**. Awards
reported as coming from multiple state programs are folded into **State**.
**Unknown** only means the granting level wasn't recorded on that record — it
is not a judgement about whether the award is real or verified.

## What "Capped" means

The award extract Incenti receives is capped at **10,000 records per state**.
Any state at or over that count carries a **capped** badge in the state
rankings, on the **Industries** tab's by-state view, in the **Explorer**
footer, and as a **Capped source** column marked `Y` in the by-state CSV and
XLSX exports.

For a capped state:

- Its award set is likely **incomplete** — records past the limit are simply
  not in the extract.
- Its **award count is not comparable** to an uncapped state's. The Explorer
  footer and the Compare group-leader footnote both say so.
- Dollar figures should be read as a floor, not a total.

The cap is a property of the source extract, not a display limit — there is
no setting that lifts it.

## How recipients are classified

Award recipients are placed on NAICS 2022 industry nodes — the U.S. Census
Bureau's classification scheme — by a model-assisted batch job that runs over
the whole award dataset. Your account does not run it and cannot trigger it.

- Each result carries a **confidence** between 0 and 1. Results below the
  confidence floor (0.5 by default) are kept but stay **unclassified** rather
  than being guessed into a sector.
- Where a code came from a manual review or from the extract itself, that
  code always wins over a model-assigned one.
- On a company's **Entities & Classifications** card, the confidence is shown
  both as a number and as a tier: **High** at 0.85 and above, **Medium** at
  0.7 to 0.85, **Low** below that. An entity with no code reads **Not
  classified**, and each entity is classified on its own activity — a
  subsidiary does not inherit its parent's industry.
- The **Sector** chips on a state's **Top Recipients in XX** list are a
  different thing: they come only from manually curated labels, so most
  recipients have none, and an industry chip can legitimately report **No
  company-level leaders identified for this segment yet**.

## Program catalog coverage

A state's **Programs Offered** coverage tier is derived every time the list
is read, from how many verified programs are on file against a benchmark
count of how many that state is expected to have:

| Tier    | Rule                                                              | What the screen shows                                                            |
| ------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| None    | No verified programs                                              | "No verified programs for X yet", with chips for jurisdictions that do have them |
| Partial | Anything below the full bar                                       | "Coverage in progress — N programs verified so far of an estimated M"            |
| Full    | Verified ÷ benchmark is 0.9 or higher, and a benchmark is on file | No coverage banner                                                               |

A state with programs on file but **no benchmark** can never read full —
without a denominator, completeness cannot honestly be claimed. Only verified
records are ever served; drafts under review are invisible. Coverage counts
sunset programs too, and narrowing the list with filters never changes the
tier — a filter changes what you see, not how completely the state is
catalogued.

### The industry filter rule

Picking an industry chip on the **Programs** tab does three things:

1. Programs tagged to that industry match, are listed first, and are the
   only ones counted in the **N of M programs match the current filters**
   line.
2. Programs with **no** industry tags at all — general-purpose programs open
   to any industry — are still listed, because they are genuinely available.
   They are not counted in the match number.
3. Programs tagged only to **other** industries are removed.

That is why the list can be longer than the match count, and the report's
Programs Offered section carries the note "Includes untagged general-purpose
programs available to any industry; industry-specific matches are listed
first."

## How often the data refreshes

**Award data is event-driven.** There is no schedule: the dataset is
re-ingested whenever a new extract is loaded. Extracts have historically
arrived a few times a year. A monthly watchdog warns Incenti internally once
90 days have passed without a successful ingest, so a silently ageing dataset
gets noticed.

**The program catalog is also event-driven per state** — a state is
re-published when its catalog work lands. On top of that, a **weekly** sweep
(Mondays) flags two things for an Incenti reviewer: verified programs whose
last-verified date has aged past 11 months, keeping every record inside a
12-month re-verification target, and legislative bill matches that suggest a
program may have changed. Each program row shows its own **Verified Mon
YYYY** date, so you can always see how fresh a specific entry is.

Within a session, program and coverage responses are cached in your browser
for about an hour; reloading the page picks up anything newer.

## Momentum, top recipients and list sizes

**Momentum Leaders** ranks states by the share of their lifetime tracked
value awarded in the **last five years** of the dataset — not by how much
they awarded. A small state that concentrated its activity recently can
outrank a much larger one.

**Top Recipients in a state** ranks by value captured **in that state**; the
**Biggest Recipients Nationwide** and **Companies** leaderboards rank by
value captured **nationwide**, so the same company can sit in a different
position in each.

Fixed list sizes worth knowing:

| List                                     | Rows                             |
| ---------------------------------------- | -------------------------------- |
| Momentum Leaders (Overview)              | 6                                |
| Biggest Recipients Nationwide (Overview) | 8                                |
| Biggest Incentive Recipients (Companies) | 25                               |
| Company search results                   | 10 (needs at least 2 characters) |
| Top Recipients on a state profile        | 10                               |
| Top recipients at an industry node       | 25                               |
| Explorer award records shown at once     | 500                              |

## Common questions

**Q: Why is the Tracked Value here smaller than the total I saw last month, or than the Total Tracked on the printed State Report?**
A: They are measuring different things. The **Tracked Value (2008+,
normalized)** KPI covers awards from 2008 onward, excludes bundled megadeals
and caps extreme outliers at the 99.9th percentile. The **Total Tracked**
figure on the printable **State Report**, and the records on **Explorer**,
are the raw all-time numbers with none of that applied. Neither is wrong —
use the normalized figure when you're comparing states, and the raw figure
when you're citing one state's full record.

**Q: What exactly counts as a megadeal?**
A: A megadeal is an award filed as a bundled package — several incentive
mechanisms rolled into one headline number for one project. They sit in the
**Megadeal (Bundled)** category, are excluded from every blended dollar
figure, and are shown in full on the **Megadeals** tab. The "How this is
normalized" footnote prints how many were excluded and what they were worth.

**Q: How is the ICS calculated, and what are the weights?**
A: Typical Award Size 25%, Large-Award Share 30%, Recency 20%, Category
Diversity 25% — each scored 0–100 and blended to a 0–100 total. See
[The Incentive Competitiveness Score](#the-incentive-competitiveness-score)
for how each component is scaled. The same weights are printed on the ICS
component bars on the state profile and in the report, so the score always
reconciles with what's on screen.

**Q: Why is my state's ICS grey, or marked "Limited"?**
A: Because it has under $50 million in disclosed award value or fewer than 30
disclosed awards. Two of the four components fall back to national medians in
that case, so the score is shown in grey and flagged to tell you it rests on
thin data rather than on the state's own record.

**Q: Does "Capped" mean Incenti is hiding records from me?**
A: No. The cap is on the source extract — 10,000 records per state — so the
records simply aren't in the data anywhere. It means that state's award
**count** can't be compared with an uncapped state's, and its dollar totals
should be read as a floor.

**Q: Does the Source column reading "Unknown" mean the award is unverified?**
A: No. It only means the record didn't say which level of government granted
it. Every award in the dataset is a disclosed award; "Unknown" is a gap in
one field, not a doubt about the award.

**Q: Why does "Top Recipients in TX" show a Sector for some companies and not others?**
A: Those Sector chips come only from manually curated labels, not from the
automated NAICS classification. Most recipients don't have one yet, so a chip
appearing is the exception rather than the rule. The NAICS codes you see on a
company's **Entities & Classifications** card are the automated ones, and
they cover far more entities.

**Q: How often is the award data refreshed, and when was it last updated?**
A: It refreshes whenever a new extract is ingested rather than on a schedule
— historically a few times a year. The **Year Range** KPI on Overview shows
the span the current dataset actually covers, which is the quickest read on
how current it is. If you need the exact ingest date, ask Incenti support.

**Q: Why does the Programs tab say "12 of 30 programs match" but list more than 12?**
A: Because general-purpose programs with no industry tags stay in the list —
they really are available to your industry — but aren't counted as
industry-specific matches. The 12 is the count of programs tagged to the
industry you picked.

## Related

- [Incentive Intelligence](https://kb.incenti.co/insights/incentive-intelligence.md)
- [Reports and exports from the Incentives screen](https://kb.incenti.co/insights/incentive-reports-and-exports.md)
- [Ask Insights](https://kb.incenti.co/insights/ask-insights.md)
- [Insights overview and data coverage](https://kb.incenti.co/insights/overview-and-data-coverage.md)
